hkmaly

Dirty? I don't see any dirt ... this is pretty clean comics.

I got you were trying, I just didn't find it funny enough to not nitpick. While slamming into wall would probably result in more serious injury than what's shown (unless the wall is from some shock-absorbing elastic material like rubber or polyurethane, instead of rock as it seem to be), it's still closer to normal physics than coyote-level cartoon physics. Note that besides the possibility of the puzzle having some protective effect, it's also possible NANASE has some protective magic on her. Remember how the scarf was enough to keep her warm. Feels like a "George of the Jungle" situation: The tree gets you knocked out. Although, the pins sure look denser than they seem. Not only the pins. She likely hit the floor multiple times while rolling.

http://egscomics.com/egsnp/nanasecraft-10 It is possible the idea of choosing the third indentation was not so logical as it seemed to be ... also, humans can make reasonably round cylinder, but not sphere. But hey, magic is involved.

Human run over by train is NOT flat as a pancake. Too heterogeneous. That can only happen in cartoon physics. (Also, in cartoon physics, character flat as a pancake is generally just injured, not dead.)

Not with this big pins. Although it sure looks that way. Was she already unconscious after multiple hits to head at the point she hit the wall, or was she protected until transformed? Didn't you notice that the expected indentation is NOT there?

http://egscomics.com/sketchbook/2018-036 So far it seems Raven is losing that war. And Justin, didn't you already decided after the Grace's party that changing sex is not the right way how to get guys?

Asking Sarah if she was right or left handed might have been Nanase's way of flipping a coin or something, head=left, tails=right kinda thing, no real meaning other than a decision maker. I would suspect that the middle indentation could have been if Sarah said she was ambidextrous. That would be very unfair coin flip.

I referred to Nanase's reasoning that she should choose third indentation because Sarah is right-handed. Looking how she shoved her, I find hard to believe it mattered ... unless magic was looking for that.

http://egscomics.com/egsnp/nanasecraft-09 Ok, I was mistaken in previous strip ; apparently there IS enough place. Although I still think that the perspective in last panel of previous strip was not ideal ... Also, yes, this is weird even compared to games I played (but maybe I didn't played correct games ...) ... yet Nanase takes it as normal. In Harry Potter, characters at least have REASON why to be familiar with bizarre things ... how often Nanase encountered puzzle like this to take it in such stride?

That's something already mentioned and taken care for (see comments).

http://egscomics.com/sketchbook/2018-035 Definitely hard to recognize.

She's not blue.

http://egscomics.com/comic/tlod-031 ... I still think it would make sense if Rhoda make HERSELF bigger, to tower properly over them. Also, what has Diane's opinion on Justin to do with this? ... yeah, it's unfair, but I can totally imagine someone being ok with girls liking girls and still consider boys liking boys incorrect.

No, that's "this" page Isn't the normal number of pins 9? Oh, right ... Europe versus US. Anyway, I expected 16, that would be really too much.

Tempted? Maybe. But I think his shock would be enough. Diane: "Shut up" Justin: "I didn't said anything" I don't remember ever catching myself with it. Now ... does it mean I never mangled it? Or ... (Meanwhile, I regularly need to look how many d's Tedd has.)

Kitsune is Japanese for Fox, Nanase named her decoy summon "Fox" and Not_Tengu referred to Nanase as "Fox Niece" so I would guess there's significance to it being either Noriko's maiden name, in which case Nanase's parents might have taken the wife's name rather than husband's name. or Noriko maybe ran off with Papa Kitsune's brother. Kitsune sounds like name which actually goes back to the elf who started Nanase's "royal" line of magic users - or to the IMMORTAL who started it. And look at Mr. Kitsune ... does he LOOK as someone who would complain when Mrs. Kitsune informs him that she's keeping her name due to tradition?

Well, she has choice of looking forward to it or not ; obviously, she has NO way to find and contact immortal, even young one, and neither a way to prevent Pandora tackle-glomping her from any direction she chooses (you think from behind is bad? What about from above? Or from BELOW?) The "she never told" seems even more telling. It might even imply they talked afterwards. Also, he does not REMEMBER her full name. That means she TOLD him. And, presumably, he told her his name.

Isn't the usual number of skittles lower? Also, unless the perspective is wrong, there is not enough space. Unless ... they are looking at the skittles from the OTHER side. However, I find more likely they are supposed to push those skittles to the holes in front of them.

How would you scale confronting her grandmother, who sort of died? Obviously, she doesn't have the OPTION to contact her currently, but I don't think she's looking forward to it either ... No, she just repeated her original assumption. Of course, this assumption seems to be wrong: Adrian wouldn't wonder why she never told him if she didn't have means to contact him.

Well it definitely doesn't make sense as content of actual crypt. There is no MOTIVATION for builders of crypt to make something open if the one opening it is CLEVER. It may make sense if it works as password lock, but then it's not something you can break just by thinking in general - you need the same kind of thinking people cracking passwords are doing, and you need to know a lot about people who build the crypt. But, if the crypt is actually constructed by immortal with the goal of making fun of the people entering it and trying to solve the puzzles ... or some sort of test to determine if you are worth entering ...

Wasn't it revealed that the J stood for "Just" as in Arthur, Just Arthur? That's not "relevation", it's just how Dan imagines it.

Diane: "You mean you didn't noticed Nanase floating around the school?" While true that Diane knows more about magic than Rhoda assumes, it would be hard to pinpoint what exactly would warrant this reaction, because the existence of magic itself is something which can't be considered secret on their school. (Also ... Raven was back teaching way too quickly, what is he, a wizard?)

IF it stands for something. Remember B.J. Hunnicutt? But doesn't matter: We know both first name and last name. Middle name doesn't count

Looking over list of awakened teenagers (besides Tedd) - Nanase, Elliot, Ellen, Susan, Justin, Rhoda - I think if anybody would be wizard in technical sense we would know it. The same would be true for Sarah or Catalina, because Pandora would say that. Meaning, unless Diane turns out to be wizard instead of "just" having summoning talent, we would need to manage with Tedd and Ashley. ... well, Akiko would be another candidate, but she's not teenager nor dreaming yet.

Last names are a precious resource in EGS. I think the only characters who have first and last names besides the Main Eight are Matthew Cohen, Carol Brown, Akiko Kitsune, Adrian Raven, and Catalina Bobcat. You'd think Diane would have a last name by now; maybe by the end of this entire arc which is named after her. I'm rooting for "Holmes". I don't care what name her adoptive parents gave her ; she's Diane Raven for me. And Noriko Verres, unless you don't count her assuming she no longer has that name after divorce. And Andy Debtman. Jim Tolkiberry. John Troutman. Also Mr and Mrs Dunkel, Mr and Mrs Brown, Mr and Mrs Pompoms ... and Dr. Germahn, Mr. Tensaided, Mr. Guyur ... principals and some teachers ...